Monmouth County’s Best Chicken Parmigiana Destinations Revealed

ByEthan Pineridge

A heated debate over New Jersey’s best chicken parmigiana has culminated in a definitive guide for Monmouth County food enthusiasts. Local food critics and restaurant-goers have weighed in on where to find the most exceptional versions of this beloved Italian-American classic throughout the region.

According to a recent survey by WJRZ, chicken parmigiana remains one of the most ordered dishes across Monmouth County’s extensive Italian restaurant scene. The perfect balance of tender chicken, crispy breading, flavorful sauce, and melted mozzarella has earned certain establishments particular recognition among discerning diners.

Top Contenders for Monmouth’s Best Chicken Parm

Buona Sera in Red Bank ranks as the number one destination for chicken parmigiana enthusiasts, according to local food experts. The restaurant’s perfectly breaded cutlets, exceptional sauce, and freshly melted mozzarella have earned it top honors among Monmouth County establishments.

“Everything I have ever eaten here is outstanding,” noted one WJRZ reviewer, who praised owner Chris for creating a welcoming atmosphere alongside the restaurant’s “exquisite” chicken preparations. The establishment has developed a reputation for consistency and attention to detail that keeps customers returning.

Molinari’s Restaurant, despite its unassuming strip mall location, secured the second position with chicken parmigiana that food critics describe as “fantastic” with sauce that’s “out of this world.” Local food enthusiasts have repeatedly emphasized that some of Monmouth County’s culinary gems are hiding in unexpected locations.

Hidden Gems and Local Favorites

Dusal’s Italian Restaurant in Freehold has earned recognition on both the WJRZ and 94.3 The Point lists of exceptional chicken parmigiana destinations. The BYOB establishment in a strip mall setting has developed a dedicated following for its unpretentious atmosphere and remarkable food quality.

Squan Tavern in Manasquan has built a reputation for versatility, offering outstanding chicken parmigiana in multiple formats. “Whether you get the chicken parm dinner, sub, stromboli or chicken parm pizza, you’re in for a treat,” reported a WJRZ food critic who praised the establishment’s consistent quality.

Illiano’s in Ocean Township earned recognition for its “juicy tender cutlets with a crispy exterior, topped with flavorful tomato sauce and soft melted mozzarella.” The family-operated business has become a neighborhood staple, drawing loyal customers with both its chicken and eggplant parmigiana variations.

Innovative Takes on a Classic Dish

The Galley in Asbury Park has distinguished itself with innovative approaches to the traditional dish. Their chicken vodka parm, served on cheese garlic bread, has been described as a transcendent experience by devoted customers. The restaurant’s use of buttermilk-brined organic Bell & Evans chicken breast has been credited for its exceptional quality.

Jimmy’s Italian Restaurant rounds out the top recommendations with portions described as “enough to feed 2 people.” Their preparation achieves the coveted combination of crispy exterior and tender interior, generously covered in “fantastic tomato sauce and a boatload of mozzarella.”

Regional Recognition Beyond Monmouth

According to 94.3 The Point, several Monmouth County establishments have earned statewide recognition for their chicken parmigiana. Spano’s in Point Pleasant Beach, Trama’s Trattoria in Long Branch, Lubrano’s Trattoria in Manasquan, and Johnny Piancone’s in Long Branch all received mentions in their comprehensive survey of New Jersey’s finest versions of the dish.

The passion for perfect chicken parmigiana extends throughout the Garden State, with enthusiasts often willing to travel significant distances for exceptional versions. Ocean County contenders like Johnny G’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Toms River and Italy’s Best in Lakehurst have developed devoted followings that draw visitors from neighboring Monmouth County.

For those seeking the pinnacle of chicken parmigiana perfection, these expert recommendations provide a roadmap to Monmouth County’s most impressive offerings of this Italian-American classic.

Similar Posts