Florida vs. New Jersey: Study Compares State Education Systems

A comprehensive new study comparing educational outcomes between Florida and New Jersey has revealed significant differences in achievement metrics, funding approaches, and policy priorities between the two states’ education systems. The analysis, conducted by researchers at the Education Policy Research Institute, examined standardized test scores, graduation rates, college readiness, and various resource allocation measures across both states, according to U.S. News & World Report.

The research comes amid ongoing national debates about educational approaches, with Florida and New Jersey often representing contrasting models in terms of funding levels, teacher compensation, standardized testing emphasis, and school choice policies. The study’s findings highlight how different policy approaches have produced varying outcomes across multiple educational metrics.

Headlines Trending Right Now:

Achievement Metrics Favor New Jersey

New Jersey consistently outperformed Florida across most standardized achievement measures examined in the study. The Garden State ranked 2nd nationally in fourth-grade reading proficiency compared to Florida’s 22nd place position, while showing even larger advantages in eighth-grade math, where New Jersey ranked 1st compared to Florida’s 33rd place standing.

“The achievement gap between these states is most pronounced in mathematics and science, particularly in middle and high school,” explained Dr. Jennifer Martinez, the study’s lead researcher. “While both states show relatively strong early literacy outcomes, New Jersey maintains strong performance through secondary education, whereas Florida shows more significant performance drops in later grades.”

College readiness metrics similarly favored New Jersey, with 72% of students taking at least one Advanced Placement exam and 68% earning qualifying scores, compared to Florida’s 56% participation and 48% qualifying rates. New Jersey’s high school graduation rate of 91% also exceeded Florida’s 86%, according to Education Week.

Funding and Resource Disparities

One of the most significant differences identified in the study involves education funding. New Jersey ranks second nationally in per-pupil spending at approximately $24,300 per student, while Florida ranks 43rd at approximately $10,100 per student – a disparity of more than $14,000 per pupil annually.

“This funding gap translates to substantial differences in resources available to schools,” Martinez noted. “New Jersey schools typically offer smaller class sizes, higher teacher salaries, more extensive support services, and greater investments in facilities and technology.”

Teacher compensation shows particularly stark contrasts, with New Jersey’s average teacher salary of $87,200 ranking among the highest nationally, while Florida’s average of $51,800 falls below the national average. This disparity contributes to different teacher recruitment and retention patterns, with New Jersey experiencing significantly lower teacher turnover rates.

Florida education officials emphasize that their approach focuses on efficiency and targeted investments rather than overall spending levels. State Education Commissioner Michael Wilson told researchers that Florida’s model “prioritizes directing resources to evidence-based initiatives rather than simply increasing overall funding without clear return-on-investment metrics.”

Contrasting Policy Approaches

The study identified fundamental philosophical differences in educational governance between the two states. Florida has embraced a centralized approach with significant state-level control over curriculum, extensive standardized testing, and school accountability measures linked to student performance. New Jersey maintains a more decentralized system with greater local district autonomy and less emphasis on high-stakes testing.

“These states represent different schools of thought regarding educational governance,” explained Robert Chen, education policy analyst at the Brookings Institution. “Florida’s model emphasizes standardized measurement, performance-based funding, and state-directed reform initiatives. New Jersey’s approach provides more local control while maintaining substantial state financial support.”

School choice policies also differ substantially, with Florida operating one of the nation’s most extensive voucher and scholarship programs allowing public education funds to follow students to private schools. New Jersey has a more limited approach to school choice, focusing primarily on charter schools and interdistrict public school choice programs.

The conservative Heritage Foundation has praised Florida’s approach, with education fellow Sarah Thompson telling Fox News that the state “achieves remarkably competitive outcomes while spending far less and offering families unprecedented educational freedom.”

Demographic Considerations and Equity Metrics

Researchers noted that demographic differences between the states influence educational outcomes and resource needs. Florida serves a student population with a higher percentage of English language learners (12.8% compared to New Jersey’s 7.2%) and a higher poverty rate (19.5% compared to 14.2%).

“Comparing education systems must account for different student populations and their unique needs,” Martinez emphasized. “Florida faces different challenges in terms of student mobility, language diversity, and concentration of poverty in certain districts.”

When examining achievement gaps between demographic groups, the study found mixed results. New Jersey showed smaller gaps between white students and their Black and Hispanic peers in reading achievement, while Florida demonstrated somewhat smaller gaps in math outcomes. Both states continue to struggle with persistent achievement disparities along socioeconomic lines.

Pandemic Response and Recovery

The study also compared how each state’s education system responded to and recovered from pandemic disruptions. Florida reopened schools for in-person instruction earlier, while New Jersey maintained remote and hybrid models for longer periods in most districts.

“Florida’s earlier return to in-person instruction appears to have mitigated some pandemic-related learning losses, particularly for younger students,” Martinez noted. “However, New Jersey’s more substantial investments in digital infrastructure and supplemental support services during reopening have accelerated recovery over the past year.”

Post-pandemic test scores show both states have made progress in recovering from learning disruptions, though neither has fully returned to pre-pandemic achievement levels. Florida showed stronger initial recovery in elementary reading, while New Jersey demonstrated faster rebounds in secondary math performance.

Lessons for Other States

Researchers suggest that rather than viewing the comparison as a competition, policymakers should consider which elements from each model might be adaptable to their own contexts. The study identifies specific practices from both states that show promise for broader application.

“Florida’s early literacy initiatives and streamlined teacher certification pathways for career-changers demonstrate impressive results and cost-effectiveness,” Martinez explained. “Meanwhile, New Jersey’s professional development model for teachers and comprehensive approach to school funding provide valuable frameworks for states seeking to strengthen educator quality and address resource equity.”

The researchers conclude that the contrasting approaches reflect different priorities and values regarding education, with neither system representing a perfect model. They suggest that the most effective education policies often combine elements from different approaches while remaining responsive to local contexts and needs.

“The Florida-New Jersey comparison illustrates that there are multiple paths to educational improvement,” Chen concluded. “The most successful states tend to maintain consistent focus on their chosen strategies rather than frequently changing direction, while remaining willing to adapt specific elements when evidence suggests better approaches.”

Headlines Trending Right Now: