When Personal Becomes Public: The Celebrity Sales Trend Raising Eyebrows
An increasing number of public figures are marketing personal items—such as worn clothing or bathwater—to devoted fans. While some applaud their entrepreneurial spirit, others question whether the boundaries of fame are being pushed too far.
The debate is heating up online as more celebrities embrace this unconventional revenue stream. Social media reactions range from enthusiasm to concern about the implications for celebrity culture.
Image Source: NJBreakingNews.com
These Hidden Posts Are Packed With Genius Ideas
- 15 Celebs Who Quietly Launched Billion-Dollar Companies
- Who’s the Wealthiest Kardashian in 2025? We Ranked Them All
- 25 Side Hustles That Actually Make Real Money
The Boundary-Breaking Business Model
Celebrity culture has reached a new frontier where the most intimate aspects of stars’ lives become commercial products. Sydney Sweeney’s recent collaboration with Dr. Squatch to create soap bars containing her actual bathwater represents the latest example of how public figures are monetizing previously private experiences.
According to The Sun, the “Euphoria” actress produced 5,000 limited-edition “Bathwater Bliss” soap bars, each priced at $8 and accompanied by authentication certificates. The collaboration emerged from fan requests after Sweeney appeared in a provocative Dr. Squatch advertisement featuring her in a bubble bath.
This trend extends far beyond bathwater. Former Page 3 model Katie Price announced plans to sell framed sets of used underwear for £350 each, while former Atomic Kitten singer Kerry Katona generates substantial income through OnlyFans by selling personal items including used undergarments for up to £100 per set. These ventures represent a fundamental shift in how celebrities view their personal boundaries and commercial potential.
Digital Platforms Fuel the Revolution
The rise of direct-to-consumer platforms has enabled celebrities to bypass traditional gatekeepers and sell personal items directly to fans. OnlyFans, Patreon, eBay, and specialized resale websites allow stars to maintain complete control over pricing, production, and distribution while capturing 100% of revenue from sales.
The Kardashian family launched Kardashian Kloset in 2019, a sophisticated resale platform offering pieces directly from their personal wardrobes. Run by Robert Kardashian Sr.’s first cousin, the site features collections from each family member spanning women’s, men’s, and children’s clothing. Despite criticism over pricing, the platform demonstrates strong demand for celebrity-worn items.
According to BuzzFeed, social media reactions to these ventures have been mixed but predominantly supportive, with fans expressing excitement about celebrity personal item sales. The direct engagement possible through social platforms has created new opportunities for stars to gauge and respond to fan interest in real-time.
The Public Debate Intensifies
The trend has sparked significant debate about the appropriate boundaries between celebrity public personas and private lives. Critics argue that selling intimate personal items commodifies celebrity in concerning ways, while supporters view it as empowering stars to control their own narratives and financial destinies.
Relationship expert Dr. Annabelle Knight from Lovehoney provided context for the psychological appeal of celebrity personal items. She explained that these purchases satisfy deep human needs for connection and intimacy, creating “a feeling of intimacy, even if it’s one-sided,” comparable to keeping meaningful mementos from romantic relationships.
However, Knight also noted that not all motivations are sexual, with many buyers seeking emotional connection, social status signaling, or collector satisfaction. The complexity of fan motivations makes simple judgments about the trend difficult, as different buyers approach these purchases with vastly different intentions and expectations.
Celebrity Empowerment vs. Exploitation Concerns
Industry experts emphasize that modern celebrity personal item sales often represent empowerment rather than exploitation. Unlike historical situations where third parties might profit from celebrity connections, today’s stars maintain complete control over their offerings and pricing strategies.
Former Baywatch actress Brande Roderick, who sells worn pajamas with autographs on eBay for £110, told Fox News Digital that her online ventures provide financial stability while allowing her to pursue acting and producing projects. She described OnlyFans as providing “total control” over her image and content, contrasting it favorably with traditional modeling arrangements.
Image Source: NJBreakingNews.com
Branding expert Nick Ede told The Sun that celebrities like Sweeney demonstrate sophisticated understanding of their public personas and fan relationships. He emphasized that modern celebrity culture revolves around direct fan engagement, making personal item sales strategically sound from marketing perspectives rather than desperate attempts at relevance.
Historical Context and Modern Evolution
Celebrity personal effects have always held special value, but digital platforms have transformed their accessibility and commercial potential. Scarlett Johansson’s 2008 auction of a used tissue for over $6,523 (donated to charity) demonstrated early market potential for unusual celebrity items, predicting today’s more sophisticated offerings.
British influencer Belle Delphine pioneered the modern bathwater market in 2019, selling “Gamergirl Bath Water” for $30 per jar and earning $18,000 within three days. Her success proved significant demand existed for unconventional celebrity products and inspired subsequent offerings from mainstream celebrities seeking new revenue streams.
According to LADbible, Sweeney’s decision represents a calculated response to fan demand rather than opportunistic exploitation. The actress noticed social media comments requesting bathwater and decided to fulfill that interest through a legitimate business partnership with established soap manufacturer Dr. Squatch.
Social Media’s Role in Boundary Dissolution
Social media platforms have fundamentally altered the relationship between celebrities and fans by creating illusions of personal intimacy through constant content sharing. Instagram, TikTok, and Twitter offer glimpses into stars’ private lives, making personal item purchases feel like natural extensions of existing emotional connections.
This digital intimacy has normalized previously taboo interactions between celebrities and fans. When stars share details about their daily routines, personal struggles, and private moments, fans develop parasocial relationships that create demand for more tangible connections through personal item purchases.
The feedback loop between social media engagement and commercial opportunities has created new pressures for celebrities to share increasingly personal content. Stars who successfully navigate this landscape often find substantial financial rewards, while those who miscalculate face potential backlash from both fans and critics.
Future Implications and Industry Concerns
As this trend continues evolving, industry observers express mixed feelings about its long-term implications for celebrity culture. While some celebrate the democratization of celebrity commerce and increased star autonomy, others worry about the psychological effects on both celebrities and fans of commodifying intimate personal experiences.
Ede predicted that “we might see some other stars dipping their toes in things that aren’t just bath water” as the trend expands beyond current boundaries. The success of early adopters suggests strong consumer demand that may attract more mainstream celebrities to unconventional merchandising approaches.
The key challenge moving forward will be establishing healthy boundaries that protect both celebrities and fans while allowing for innovative commercial relationships. As technology continues advancing and social media platforms evolve, the definition of appropriate celebrity-fan interactions will likely continue shifting in unpredictable directions.
Whether this represents cultural progress or concerning commodification remains hotly debated, but the trend’s growth suggests that the boundaries between personal and public life in celebrity culture will continue blurring as stars and fans navigate new forms of digital-age intimacy and commerce.
